"Joltin' Joe" was a 13-time all-star, three-time MVP, and according to Ted Williams, was "the greatest all-around player I ever saw." Of course, he holds the current record for consecutive games with a hit, at 56, accomplished in 1941.
Nicklas Lidstrom is easily better than Joe DiMaggio. Joltin' Joe was great, but Lidstrom will forever be remembered as a better athlete in his respective sport 30 years down the road.
Joltin' Albert doesnt have much of a ring to it, but his numbers will eclipse Joe's. 9× All-Star selection (2001, 2003–2010) World Series champion (2006) 3× NL MVP (2005, 2008, 2009) 2× NL Hank Aaron Award (2003, 2009) 6× Silver Slugger Award (2001, 2003–2004, 2008–2010) 2× Gold Glove Award (2006,2010) 2001 NL Rookie of the Year 6× NL Player of the Month Award 2004 NLCS MVP 2008 Roberto Clemente Award 2003 NL Batting champion 2009–2010 NL home run champion 2010 NL RBI champion Otherwise, I give it up to Nicklas Lidstrom. So Joe gets 3rd.
Albert Pujols is a great player, but he's not in DiMaggio's league. Albert might catch his numbers, but he also didn't spend 3 years in his prime fighting overseas in a war (DiMaggio didn't play baseball from age 28 to 30). DiMaggio and Pujols have both won 3 MVP awards. DiMaggio is the only player in major league history to go to the All-Star game every year he played. And with Dimaggio as their best player, the Yankees won the pennant 10 times, and the World Series 9 times. Albert doesn't even come close there. Then there's Dimaggio's 56 game hitting streak. Pujols is a Hall of Famer, but DiMaggio casts a shadow over Albert.
You bring up a good point. That's a much overlooked fact, that DiMaggio spent 3 of his prime playing years fighting in a war overseas. Add his contribution to his country to his baseball prowess and you can understand why DiMaggio is so impressive and was such an icon of his era.
Denis Potvin, Nick Lidstrom, Johnny Bench other worthy fives
ReplyDeleteGeorge Brett!
ReplyDeleteIn the next decade, David Wright will be worthy to mention.
ReplyDeletebench - hornung
ReplyDeleteBrooks Robinson
ReplyDeleteNick Lidstrom, all the way, greatest European in NHL history
ReplyDeleteAlbert Pujols
ReplyDeleteHank Greenberg. "He was one of the truly great hitters and when I first saw him at bat, he made my eyes pop out." - Joe DiMaggio, of Greenberg
ReplyDelete#5 GEORGE BRETT. BATTING TITLES IN 3 DIFFERENT DECADES. WORLS SERIES CHAMPION 1985.
ReplyDeleteJohnny Bench!!
ReplyDeleteNicklas Lidstrom is easily better than Joe DiMaggio. Joltin' Joe was great, but Lidstrom will forever be remembered as a better athlete in his respective sport 30 years down the road.
ReplyDeleteJoltin' Albert doesnt have much of a ring to it, but his numbers will eclipse Joe's.
ReplyDelete9× All-Star selection (2001, 2003–2010)
World Series champion (2006)
3× NL MVP (2005, 2008, 2009)
2× NL Hank Aaron Award (2003, 2009)
6× Silver Slugger Award (2001, 2003–2004, 2008–2010)
2× Gold Glove Award (2006,2010)
2001 NL Rookie of the Year
6× NL Player of the Month Award
2004 NLCS MVP
2008 Roberto Clemente Award
2003 NL Batting champion
2009–2010 NL home run champion
2010 NL RBI champion
Otherwise, I give it up to Nicklas Lidstrom. So Joe gets 3rd.
Albert Pujols is a great player, but he's not in DiMaggio's league. Albert might catch his numbers, but he also didn't spend 3 years in his prime fighting overseas in a war (DiMaggio didn't play baseball from age 28 to 30).
ReplyDeleteDiMaggio and Pujols have both won 3 MVP awards. DiMaggio is the only player in major league history to go to the All-Star game every year he played. And with Dimaggio as their best player, the Yankees won the pennant 10 times, and the World Series 9 times. Albert doesn't even come close there. Then there's Dimaggio's 56 game hitting streak.
Pujols is a Hall of Famer, but DiMaggio casts a shadow over Albert.
You bring up a good point. That's a much overlooked fact, that DiMaggio spent 3 of his prime playing years fighting in a war overseas. Add his contribution to his country to his baseball prowess and you can understand why DiMaggio is so impressive and was such an icon of his era.
ReplyDeleteKevin Garnett?
ReplyDeleteFirst of all NO ONE is passing Joe D !
ReplyDeleteBut, when Pujols finishes his career he will be the #2 #5 of all time.